Originally Published: Sep 15, 2010 8:29 AM CDT
I say give the Heisman to Vince Young. Why not?
Reggie Bush has given back his 2005 Heisman Trophy amid the scandal that has turned his USC career into a disaster. So give the trophy to V.Y. He was probably the best player in college football that year anyway.
"But Toby...you cant change history!" Sure you can. Weve been over this before. Reggie Bush cheated. So why should Vince Young be punished? If the class Valedictorian is caught with the answers on her hand...theres a new Valedictorian. If the President is impeached...the V.P. moves into the big office. If for whatever reason Miss America cannot fulfill her duties...happy day for the runner-up. Its the circle of life.
Vince Young had a Heisman calibre year in 2005. Give him the statue.